This Blog has now moved to idebate.org/worlddebating - all future posts will be made there!

27 December 2008

Update from Cork Day 1

I'm back home after registering at Worlds. It seemed to be running fairly smoothly. I wasn't on any of the lists of judges (It was a bit late when I confirmed to Derek that I would be attending) but still got registered and a badge in about 10 minutes.

Keep checking back here for ongoing updates as the competition unfolds.

I'm not the only one who will be reporting. Jens from yourgermancorrespondant and Tuna from Globaldebate will also be posting some updates. There is also a facebook group giving updates.

Each of us will bring a slightly different perspective to their coverage so I'm not afraid to refer people to those blogs also (you can find a link to them on the right hand side). However as always www.debating.ie will endevour to provide the best overall coverage.

Today at Worlds 09: Day 1

The Agenda for today (Dec 27th) at Worlds in Cork is:
  • Registration
  • Hotel Transfers
  • Welcome Cocktail Party

Motions from Pan-African Universities Debating Championships

Here are the motions from the inaugural Pan-African Universities Debating Championship, held at the University of Botswana.

Round 1 - Rights
THW legalize Prostitution in All Mining Facilities

Round 2 - Economy
THW Nationalize All Natural Resources

Round 3 - Environment
THW Tie Development Aid to Investment in Green Technology

Round 4 - Money and Corruption
THW Punish Banks if their Clients Launder Money through their Bank Accounts

Round 5 - Conflicts
THW choose public criticism over quiet diplomacy in dealing with Zimbabwe

Quarters - Child Participation / Polio
THBT states should vaccinate children against polio regardless of parental consent

Semis
This House Believes That China's Increasing Investment in Africa Brings More Harm than Good

Finals
This House Believes that Africa Needs International Military Intervention to Solve her Most Dire Conflicts

23 December 2008

Happy Christmas

I would like to take this opportunity to wish all visitors to this site a happy Christmas (or holiday season). Of course if you celebrate a different religious festival at this time or even if this time of year bears no special significance for you I hope you will still accept my wish for happiness, peace and prosperity at this time and into 2009.

And in particular I would like to wish best of luck to all those travelling to worlds in Cork. I'm sure it will be a great tournament and I look forward to meeting many of you there in a few days.

If you can't be at worlds but would like to know what is happening be sure to check this site for regular updates from the championships.

Colm

CIMB WUPID Tab

The tab from the recent WUPID can be found at http://mlysn.wordpress.com/2008/12/22/cimb-wupid-08-central-find-out-where-you-stand/

There is also a video of some highlights from the event. It looks to have been a fantastic event again this year.

22 December 2008

Three Reasons Why Botswana should host Worlds 2011‏

Dear Worlds Community,
There are many reasons why the University of Botswana should host the WorldUniversities Debating Championships in 2011, but here are the 3 mostimportant - Organization, Development & Excitement

*Organization*
This is our 3rd concurrent bid for worlds. We've been preparing for worldssince May 2006 and we believe this clearly exhibits our desire to host thetournament, our long term vision and our ability to sustain an organization.We have an experienced organizing team, with anywhere from 7-15 years debateand hosting experience.

We recently hosted the biggest tournament in Africa, the first Pan-AfricanUniversities Debating Championships involving 10 African countries, morethan 30 Universities from across the African continent and many debatetrainers.

We have actively participated in the South African Debating Championshipsfor the past 9 years and are regular breakers in the tournament. Since 1997we have competed in the World Universities Debating Championship twice inStellenbosch (1997, 2003), NTU Singapore (2004), MMU Malaysia (2005), UBCVancouver (2007) and in Bangkok Thailand last year.

We have organized the Botswana schools debating tournament for the past fouryears and the Botswana inter-college championships. We know that organizingtournaments can be logistically exhaustive, random and difficult to manage.We know because we've been part of, planned and executed similar tournamentsand events before and are thus ready for the challenge.

The University of Botswana has a long and impressive track record of hostinglarge regional events. The entire tournament will take place on theUniversity of Botswana campus, which is in the city centre of Gaborone.

We have more than 50 smart classrooms, which will make excellent debatevenues, lectures halls with more than 500 persons seating capacity andcomfortable dining halls. The infrastructure to host large internationalconferences is available.

In the last two years alone, UB hosted the BOLESWA games between BotswanaLesotho Swaziland (which includes debating), a pre CHOGM Symposium for allCommonwealth Universities, the NOMA awards for the best writer, author andpublisher n Africa, the first IASTED conference in Africa (InternationalAssociation for Science and technology Development) and many more eventsthat depended upon huge conference facilities, IT support, first world classaccommodation, safe environments and easy international access.
We have incredible amount of support from the government, private sector,and NGOs. With our improved organizational team and with LogandranBalavijendran and James Dray heading the Adjudication team, we honestlybelieve we can host not just the best Worlds in Africa, but the best Worldsever.

*Development*
From 1997 to 2009 only 1 Worlds has been hosted in Africa (4 in AustralAsia,5 in Europe, 2 in North America). Yet teams from the African Continent haveparticipated in every one of them. Occasionally some institutions will maketheir first appearance, but seldom come back, it is now time that Africa isgiven a chance

In the 30 years of WUDC history, it has visited the African continent twice(Stellenbosch, South Africa, 1997 and 2003). For 2 debate generations,debaters in Africa have not had Worlds on their continent. Representation ofAfrican teams at Worlds has withered. While debate continues to flourish inpockets, it does so alone and segregated from the Worlds community. It istime we changed this.

Hosting the World Universities Debating Championships in Botswana will allowdebate to grow in Africa, because it will give us a platform to promotedebate. Members of the organizing committee of Botswana Worlds 2011 havebeen promoting debate actively in Southern Africa, mainly by runningworkshops and debate tournaments in Swaziland and Lesotho. The response, tolearn and spread debate, has been amazing. With the support of otherdebating nations in Southern Africa, we will use WUDC 2011 to plant debatinginto as many of the 52 countries in Africa as possible.

By 2011 we pledge to bring 20 African countries to Worlds for the first timeever. In the first continental tournament we organized we were able to bring10 African countries together just in a space of under four months, nextyear we plan to double the size of the tournament and even have 150 teams.There are many many countries that have shown interest to participate andcould not come this year and we are working with IDEA/OSI on assisting themto be able to attend next year.

We are currently in the process of setting up an English Speaking Union inBotswana, because of the attention and awareness we generated through ourbid for Botswana Worlds 2010. When other corporations, universities andgovernments see how huge, important and colorful the WUDC and debate is,they will be more pliable to pleas of support from hundreds of debaters intheir countries. This helps build larger debate organizations, securesupport for regional debate events and obtain funding to attend futureWorlds.

*Excitement*
At the risk of sounding fantastic, the truth is Botswana has everything. Themost stable democratic country in Africa, with a solid economy and greatinfrastructure - boasts all the comforts and excitement of any developedcity. Great shopping, clubs, bars, food, casinos, backpacking adventure,resorts and food from around the world.

Integrated into Worlds will be visits to the Mokolodi Nature Reserve, (Gameviewing, leopard petting, elephant riding and general lounging in the sun),beers at St.Claire Lion's Park, opportunities to visit the Central KalahariNature Reserve.

Botswana worlds will also be less than 6 months after the FIFA World Cupends just across the border in South Africa. This means more travelpromotions, which means more options at less cost for you!

If the WUDC is to take you somewhere you would never go or could never go onyour own, let it take you to Botswana, Africa. Let it take you to theSafari, the Okavango, the Kalahari; to the transparent, safe, democratic,pluralistic nation that is Africa's best kept secret. Let it take you toBotswana.

Please visit our website, www.botswanaworlds.com, for more updatedinformation (organization team, logistics, schedules), videos and pictures.

I will see you at Cork, and hopefully, at Botswana Worlds 2011!

Cheers
Justice Motlhabani
ConvenorBotswana Worlds 2011

Singapore Debate Open Results

From AUDC mailing list

Hi All,
The Singapore Debate Open 2008 was held over the past weekend. 44teams, from four countries competed in four preliminary rounds,quarters, semis and finals.

The results are:
Winners: Yes We Can (Joey Pang and Shrawan Saraogi)
Finalists: NTU 1 (Madhav Janakiraman and Anindya Dutta), SMU 1 (CarloCabrera and Anirban Gupta), NTU 2 (Lakshmi Balachandran and Parvathy Prem)
Semi-finalists: NUS LA (Alexander Yeo and Tan Li Feng), NUS The A-team(Ashok Rai and Amanda Lim), NYP 2 (Pirakash and Saqib), RGWG (Weige Wuand Renuka)

Top 10 Speakers:
1. Alexander Yeo (NUS LA)
2. Tan Li Feng (NUS LA)
3. Vikram Balasubramanian (Pinky and the Cripple)
3. Joey Pang (Yes We Can)
5. Madhav Janakiraman (NTU 1)
5. Lakshmi Balachandran (NTU 2)
5. Aditya Vijaya Kumar (Pinky and the Cripple)
5. Robin (Gongjiao)
5. Mark Lim (Gongjiao)
10. Anirban Gupta (SMU 1)

Motions:
Round 1: THW throw the book at Dubiya
Round 2: THW ban all anti-government protests
Round 3: THBT Iran should be engaged without preconditions
Round 4: THBT criminals should not be given the right to vote
Quarters: THBT Western economies should become more socialist
Semis: THW give its best for Gaza
Finals: THBT there are no universal human rights